Tobins' Tastes: Thanksgiving Pie Party

Monday, November 17, 2014

Thanksgiving Pie Party

Looking for more Holiday Party Ideas? Check out all of my party plans and season recipes HERE!

Pin It

I bake a lot of things from scratch for the holidays. Pies aren't one of them. Every year Justin goes on and on about how he wishes I would make pies so this year I decided to make sure that he would have plenty of pie at all of his holiday celebrations.

Since I have probably only made one pie in my entire life, I decided to grab a variety of Mrs. Smith's pies from Walmart to bring to our recent Friendsgiving celebration. Justin loves all pie flavors equally so I grabbed a Pumpkin, Cherry, Very Berry, Dutch Apple and Traditional Apple Pie as well as Cool Whip for topping. I also got an extra Dutch Apple and Very Berry to make mini mason jar pies too.

The night before the party I baked up all the pies so that I would have minimal prep in the morning. We were helping the hostess decorate so I wanted to not be stressed out. I made an Apple Pie Spice Cool Whip to go in the mini pies and for topping the regular pie slices and I had made that the night before too. It was so nice to be able to get everything done ahead of time and Mrs. Smith's makes it so simple to bake the pies right out of the freezer.

The morning of, I assembled the mason jar pies and stored them in the fridge for later. I originally made the mason jar pies for convenience since dessert is often eaten while standing around mingling and pie in a jar is way easier to eat than an actual slice is.

But as it turns out, the pie jars were a huge hit. Every single one was eaten. My personal favorite was the Dutch Apple with Apple Spice Cool Whip, toffee and a salted caramel drizzle but people got pretty excited about the Very Berry with chocolate sauce too. This also further proved my theory that everything tastes even better in a jar.

My friend Aaron was the hostess this year and she had an adorable decor theme of burlap, whites and metallics so I decided to go with plates and napkins to match. I also added a little sparkly burlap ribbon to my mason jars. It only took a few minutes to do and it made me so happy. I think the guests appreciated it too. Stay tuned tomorrow for a Friendsgiving post with photos of all of Aaron's amazing decor and tablescape.

I wanted to have a little hot beverage station to go with the desserts so I pre-made some hot spiced cider and brought it over to the party in an insulated airpot and even though it was made at 3:30 in the afternoon it was still "nuclear hot" according to the guys at 10pm.

I couldn't find hot beverage cups to match my plates and napkins so I bought basic white cups with coffee sleeves and added a little gold and silver washi tape to them so they would go with the decor. Little things like that make me irrationally happy when it comes to entertaining. I also put out some metallic markers so people could label their drinks (or pie plates if they were possessive like that).

When setting up the pie table I used cake plates and three tiered dessert stands to give some height and depth to the table. I used a mason jar with burlap ribbon around it to hold my spoons and I went with disposable pie cutters and plates because I didn't want to be digging through all the trash for my servingware and it made clean up very easy. I made sure to save the box the mason jars came in because it makes for a great way to store and transport mini desserts. 

To make the dessert station interactive I set up a chalkboard voting station where guests vote for their favorite type of pie. The voting (and the majority of the dessert eating) didn't take place until well after dark so I didn't get a shot of the final tally but I am pretty sure that Dutch Apple won. Although I am positive that if the mason jar pies had a number, they would have won by a landslide.

Want to save on Mrs. Smith's pies and Cool Whip for your next party? Be sure to print out this coupon to save $1.00 on Mrs. Smith’s Pie with the purchase of Cool Whip. I was able to get two prints of it and saved $2 on my purchase last week.

If you need more inspiration for the holidays, check out the Cooking Up Good website. They have recipes, sweepstakes, loyalty programs, coupons and more!  If you're looking for a new dinner idea or a chance to win some awesome prizes, be sure to check it out!

Mason Jar Pies

Dutch Apple Version:

  • 1 cooked and cooled Mrs. Smith's Dutch Apple Pie
  • Apple Pie Spice Cool Whip (see recipe below)
  • Salted Caramel Sauce
  • Toffee bits
  • Chocolate sprinkles (optional)
1.) Using an ice cream scoop, scoop out two scoops of Dutch Apple pie into the bottom of the mason jar. 

2.) Top with Apple Pie Spice Cool Whip, drizzle with caramel sauce and top with toffee bits and sprinkles. Store in the refrigerator. 

Very Berry Version:

  • 1 cooked and coole Mrs. Smith's Very Berry Pie
  • Cool Whip
  • Chocolate Sauce

1.) Using an ice cream scoop, scoop out two scoops of Very Berry pie into the bottom of the mason jar. 

2.) Top with Cool Whip and drizzle with chocolate sauce. Store in the refrigerator. 

Apple Pie Spice Cool Whip:

Mix 1/2 tablespoon of apple pie spice into a tub of Cool Whip. Store in the fridge. 


This post was sponsored by Mrs. Smith's Pies & Cool Whip. All ideas and views are my own. 


  1. This looks delish! Where do I find these jars?

    1. I purchased them at Walmart actually : ) They are just Ball Mason jars. I think Michaels sells them too.

  2. So each pie makes 6 mason jar pies?

    1. Roughly yes. You can probably get 6-8 mason jars out of each pie depending on how big your jars are and how much you fill them. Each jar is about one slice of pie if that makes sense.

  3. Love this idea!Do you know what size (or ounces)the jars you used are? Thanks!

  4. Love this idea!Do you know what size (or ounces)the jars you used are? Thanks!

  5. I don't know the exact size but they are smaller- maybe 8oz? I bought them in a twelve pack with the lids at Walmart around Thanksgiving time. Hope that helps!

  6. IIT JEE 2017 Category wise Cut Off score is available. Click here to get JEE Advanced Expected Cut Off Marks.
    IIT JEE Advanced Cut Off Marks

  7. Cinema Box App is one of the greatest app it allows you to watch the HD movies on your android device, Click here to check the process of download.
    Download Cinema Box App

  8. Fancy designer wear our website and reasonable price More…
    We Have Some For You In Your Budget For more…
    Plz visit:- pakistani Dresses

  9. Here you can get the complete details about tan number search. For more click here
    know your tan

  10. AP EAMCET Results 2017 has released, to get results and download score card.
    Click here

  11. Best tips to increase a low platelet count naturally. For more click here
    Increase platelet count naturally

  12. TS Engineering And Medical Common Entrance Test results are released, Click here to check the results and download EAMCET Rank Card.
    TS EAMCET Results 2017

  13. Oriental Insurance Company is a public sector general insurance firm in India.
    Click here for more information

  14. You can buy from our large and diverse collection of salwar kameez, party wear suits, bollywood collection, cotton kurtis, Anarrkali suits,Bollywood saree and many other products....
    We Have Some For You In Your Budget For more…
    Plz visit:- Salwar Kameez Designs

  15. Get LIC India policy & plans online at lowest premiums.
    lic of india online payment

  16. LG top loading washing machines are kinder on both your fabrics and your utility bills, for more required information

  17. Buy Frost Free Refrigerators at India's Best Online Shopping Store. Check Price in India and Buy Online. Go here for more information.
    lg frost free refrigerator price

  18. Latest Curved Tv price in India. For more details about curved tv click here
    Curved TV

  19. This is what i was looking for thak you for sharing this amazing post. keep on posting these kind of nice post
    happy independence day
    Eid Mubarak images
    Crack center

  20. Showbox and rival apps are a true source of entertainment contents that presents a comprehensive situation of an entertainment sector where we can get ourselves entertained in the method we like. Learn more about apps like showbox

  21. Really impressive post. I read it whole and going to share it with my social circules. I enjoyed your article and planning to rewrite it on my own blog.

  22. Christmas is an annual festival commemorating the birth of Jesus Christ, observed most commonly on December 25 as a religious and cultural celebration among billions of people around the world. A feast central to the Christian liturgical year, it is preceded by the season of Advent or the Nativity Fast and initiates the season of Christmastide, which historically in the West lasts twelve days and culminates on Twelfth Night in some traditions, Christmastide includes an Octave. Christmas Day is a public holiday in many of the world's nations, is celebrated religiously by a majority of Christians, as well as culturally by many non-Christians, and forms an integral part of the holiday season. In several countries, celebrating Christmas Eve has the main focus rather than Christmas Day.

  23. Have you had this question what do you want for christmas then check this fourm to find answers for your question.

  24. Thank you so much for Sharing this article Awesome post People also like this information
    Best RPG for Android Free/Paid 2017 Visit here I really really appreciate this article



  26. Thanks for sharing this nice post awesome keep sharing
    Happy New Year 2018 quotes

  27. You have a a lot of spam in your comments. Sometimes it helps to get rid of those right away.

  28. Thank you for this informative article. Looking forward to see more like thistangedco


Related Posts Plugin for WordPress, Blogger...